A Troubled and Troubling History

Peter was four. He had just started Head Start programing when his mother announced she was pregnant. It seemed almost immediately after that Peter became non-compliant with any authority. He experienced a disturbance in sleep and appetite, withdrew socially, refused to wear a seatbelt in the car, and misbehaved in public until his mother had to bring him home. Peter hit, bit, threw things, broke toys, and screamed to get his way, and developed an excessive need to be in control.
More alarmingly, Peter engaged in harmful behaviors, riding his bike across the street in front of traffic, running over a two-year-old with his bicycle, putting a pillow over his mother’s head telling her to die, and deliberately putting toys on the floor to make his grandmother fall.

Peter’s mother reported that at eight months of age, he had rolled out of the bed, resulting in an ER visit and a report of suspected child abuse. During that ER visit, Peter’s grandmother was asked to help restrain him while they took X-rays, which revealed a broken knee cap. DCFS took custody of Peter and charged the mother with neglect. He spent two days in the hospital and one night in a foster home before being returned to his mother.

I concluded that Peter’s school referral and his mother’s pregnancy had triggered the medical trauma, separation, and attachment issues that were contributing to his behavioral and emotional difficulties. In that assessment, I identified several issues for treatment, including (1) intense fear and anger at separation from attachment figures, (2) inconsistency in setting limits/boundaries and consequences for misbehavior, and (3) the use of behavior, rather than words to express himself. At the time of developing Peter’s treatment plan, I noted that his favorite act of defiance was to run outside in his birthday suit (naked). Our first task in behavior management was to have him put on his underwear before his appointment began!

Growth and Understanding through Play

Peter’s mother and grandmother were nurturing and invested in his growth and development, as well as my support team during our home play therapy visits. Books, toys, and movies were abundant in the home. Working with children, I had come to understand that they find comfort and a sense of security in the predictability in movies. Peter was no exception and movies were frequently playing when I arrived.

Using a client centered approach that incorporated themes from movies his parents had allowed him to watch like, Honey I Shrunk the Kids, Titanic, and Jaws, Peter was able to process his experience and communicate very aptly the chaos he felt both internally and externally. He would play these movies, or parts of the movie during appointments, while he built his creations, including his parents and myself with his toys, and then act out the scenes. I saw the parallels between the movies and his life experiences.

He built an elaborate shrinking machine in the living room which, I believe, reflected his feelings of being totally overwhelmed with his world and the multiple changes he was experiencing. As he adjusted to school and the birth of his sister, his shrinking machine became smaller and disappeared.

Titanic reflected the family’s chaos during the time his mother worked away from home, which took her away for extended periods, and other times resulting in her return home after Peter was in bed. The grandmother was left to assume all parenting and childcare responsibilities. Peter would rewind and replay the moment the ship would break in half and sink into the ocean in a perfect parallel to the absence of his mother. He wore out the tape! His mother quit the job.

The presence of Peter’s grandmother in his classroom as an aide helped to heal the attachment wounds that had occurred during his early infancy. She took him to school, remained in the classroom and brought him home. As Peter adjusted to the structure and routine of school and gained confidence in the return home, he became challenged by the learning process and his desire to learn took precedence over his misbehavior. Both parental figures read to him and the social stories of The Bernstein Bears, and his ability to understand and apply what he heard helped him adjust to new and changing social situations.

Peter became able to verbally express his dislike for his sister but never intentionally attempted to hurt her. He would simply pick her up and move her, even when she would unintentionally destroy one of his play creations. One of my repetitive phrases during appointments was “Use your words!” Feelings of resentment disappeared when he was able to use his words and tell his mother and grandmother he did not like his sister because she was messing up his creations. They in turn made more conscious efforts to keep her away from his projects, and to listen when he used his words.

In his play around the themes from the movie, Jaws, Peter was the captain of an imaginary boat in shark infested waters. He brought all the people and things important to him into the boat, his mother, grandmother, sister, and me to protect us. He acted out the shark attack addressing his fears about his safety and nurturing needs. He would replay this scene many times. As the boat became bigger and bigger, the shark infested waters grew smaller and ultimately disappeared. So did his disruptive and aggressive behavior.

***

Peter was phased out of treatment. His mother and grandmother were learning that withholding his movies could quickly bring misbehavior under control, while their nurturance, consistency, and attention to his safety and security needs helped to strengthen and support his positive and social behaviors. Peter was able to play with new friends and enjoy all of the experiences of school.


File under: Musings and Reflections, Child & Adolescent Therapy